No good
所在版块:悟入棋途 发贴时间:2007-11-07 08:06  评分:

用户信息
复制本帖HTML代码
高亮: 今天贴 X 昨天贴 X 前天贴 X 
In certain situations such as 2 Assistants with 2 Elephants, one side might hav moved it while the other moved only 1 shi in the whole game. This would turn into victory for one side because 3 pawn vs a full defense is a win.
Furthermore, Pawns starting from the assistant position are totally unguarded in terms of situation where pawn battles ensue.
In addition, in drawish situations previously seen, it's become a game for the one who converts over first to win the game.
What I see is that, in a long battle, this move might become the new 'wait' move without changing the overall 'pattern' of the game because the converted pawn stays in the same place.

Plus, this only applies to higher level of playing. In countries where the level of play is lower, it spoils the game; books/materials become redundant. A major revamp of the books/materials would be needed. Does chess need to change just to suit high level players?

It's true that chess games now have become boring, for even I stopped following the games from China, but this is not the way to cure the situation by changing the core defense of the king.

Changing the game like this makes Chinese Chess the laughing stock of other Chess communities. It shows how imperfect chinese chess is; easily drawn as long as one has a certain skill level.

Horrible idea.
.
欢迎来到华新中文网,踊跃发帖是支持我们的最好方法!

 相关帖子 我要回复↙ ↗回到正文
也许现在可以讨论中国象棋规则改革的探索 "仕相可以升变成兵" 棋儒   (1539 bytes , 1104reads )
也有可取之处。 几度   (1083 bytes , 308reads )
那干脆16子全都不同多好玩 一刀n断   (249 bytes , 282reads )
太复杂也不行。 几度   (183 bytes , 281reads )
三国象棋也蛮有意思的样子 一刀n断   (99 bytes , 310reads )
三国象棋确实有其独特的地方 香陵居士   (58 bytes , 245reads )
三国象棋中可以互相陷害 卷心菜   (0 bytes , 305reads )
呵呵,三国的妙处就在于此 香陵居士   (112 bytes , 236reads )
弈天上那个“飞象过河”的快乐赛还是蛮有意思 一刀n断   (151 bytes , 351reads )
国际象棋两个兵换成炮的做法 ..... not change, add on 棋人生   (39 bytes , 332reads )
二, 动过的士相就不能升变; 一刀n断   (248 bytes , 314reads )
荒诞 张辽   (260 bytes , 288reads )
谢谢大家的热烈反应, 不过,这只是探索,大家讨论不妨 ................... 棋儒   (276 bytes , 309reads )
No good sAviOr   (1328 bytes , 312reads )
It is a major change, end up, more will change to play 国际象棋.... 棋人生   (0 bytes , 260reads )