ya,, I think each indicator is only useful for particular market condition,,
所在版块：狮城财经 发贴时间：2010-01-17 21:24

用户信息
复制本帖HTML代码
高亮: 今天贴 X 昨天贴 X 前天贴 X 
for eg.: RSI is best fit for a sideway market, while MA is more suitable for a trending market...

For MA,,I believe no matter which ever time period you are using, as long as the market is trending, u will make money if your direction is correct and following your own defined rules.

For RSI, I am sure you will be well returned if you short when RSI >70 and long when RSI<30, Provided the market is sideway(rectangle movement)...

So my personal feeling is that every indicator has its own best suited market working condition and limitation.

I have tried to use RSI for each market conditions. sideway market is fairly easy to apply RSI. however, if the market is trending, either up or down, my experience is that: in a bull market, I will only long when RSI is low and divergent, rather than seeking short when RSI is high and divergent; and in a bear market, I will only short when RSI is high and devengent, rather than seeking long when RSI is low and divergent.

so the most critical question for me is what kink of market movement it is now and going to be next------ up, down or horizontal?

.
欢迎来到华新中文网，踊跃发帖是支持我们的最好方法!

　相关帖子 我要回复↙ ↗回到正文
[元创佳作]用RSI divergence 来判断trend reversal － 牛魔王 　2009-07-12 15:02 (563 bytes , 2774reads )
我一直都是只用RSI做长期和飚涨股票的筛选，满灵光的。 － 宇宙原能体 　2010-01-20 12:09 (52 bytes , 338reads )
宇兄可否详细说说遇到”飙涨“的该如何判断追不追？ － 晋海 　2010-01-20 12:32 (0 bytes , 226reads )
另一个图 － 宇宙原能体 　2010-01-20 13:34 (58 bytes , 271reads )
兄台用的chartnexus吧？ － Milky他爹 　2010-01-20 14:04 (131 bytes , 277reads )
这个RSI好极端。。。还是不是很明白，但已经很感谢了！ － 晋海 　2010-01-20 13:51 (0 bytes , 241reads )
just for discussion,, I think sth wrong,, you may check your setting first.... － 虹 　2010-01-20 13:42 (0 bytes , 307reads )
我按这样条件筛选后做的买入基本上8年来收益不错的。 － 宇宙原能体 　2010-01-20 13:47 (0 bytes , 221reads )
现粘贴一个图 － 宇宙原能体 　2010-01-20 13:04 (121 bytes , 293reads )
hi dude,, your indicator is your own defined one or default one...? － 虹 　2010-01-20 13:30 (235 bytes , 279reads )
是我查找准备要买入股票，符合条件而定的。 － 宇宙原能体 　2010-01-20 13:44 (0 bytes , 280reads )
i c,,, if it is your own logic, then fine.... － 虹 　2010-01-20 13:47 (0 bytes , 251reads )
我也不是很懂，有一点浅见，首先不能用70/30判断超买/卖，这个很重要。而应该用背离。 － 牛魔王 　2010-01-19 23:23 (321 bytes , 366reads )
好好好！ 有数学公式才清楚了。 － sgCSM 　2010-01-20 09:47 (31 bytes , 225reads )
想起曾渊沧博士在一次讲座中的一句话... － zhaijj 　2010-01-17 11:17 (158 bytes , 573reads )
ya,, I think each indicator is only useful for particular market condition,, － 虹 　2010-01-17 21:24 (1106 bytes , 508reads )
好文, 学习ing － sgCSM 　2010-01-18 00:19 (10 bytes , 201reads )
Thanks, Good point, I like this article. － 花豹 　2010-01-17 23:06 (29 bytes , 333reads )
跟牛王探讨一下…… － 香陵居士 　2010-01-17 04:26 (199 bytes , 389reads )
这似乎正是RSI的一个重要意义。。。 － 晋海 　2010-01-17 10:05 (366 bytes , 306reads )
有点问题啊：连创新高不等于连续走高吧 － 香陵居士 　2010-01-18 10:17 (64 bytes , 253reads )
我的妈！不好意思跑题一下，兄台的签名档莫非是尚老板的签名！ － 晋海 　2010-01-17 09:58 (13 bytes , 273reads )
没错啊，我是尚老板的粉丝。 － 香陵居士 　2010-01-18 10:12 (0 bytes , 256reads )
顶一下，再评论一下 ：） － 树冷 　2010-01-16 16:57 (600 bytes , 380reads )
bookmark － 晋海 　2010-01-16 15:58 (0 bytes , 229reads )
如图， BDI 和油价都有走稳要反弹的样子， DOW还能跌到哪里去呢？ － 亢牛有悔 　2009-07-14 22:28 (392 bytes , 422reads )
BDI 一起, 果然海事股就起, COSCO, NOL, 还有谁? － 亢牛有悔 　2009-07-15 14:45 (4 bytes , 377reads )
how about jaya, swiber, 也算把？ － picaqiu 　2009-07-15 15:25 (0 bytes , 282reads )
NOL今天很猛, 不过这一两天还会跌回$1.4左右. 大老们怎么看? － 飙升 　2009-07-15 15:23 (0 bytes , 295reads )
海事股还有mermaid... － zhaijj 　2009-07-15 15:22 (26 bytes , 386reads )
mermaid我套了1个多月了，6以上买的 － mkx1 　2009-07-15 15:24 (0 bytes , 283reads )
翟某进场陪你解套... － zhaijj 　2009-07-15 15:30 (36 bytes , 391reads )
翟某不过随便说说,genting卖方$0.71的3千多张票就被你扫到完了... － zhaijj 　2009-07-15 15:51 (13 bytes , 338reads )
720处3000多张被一口吃掉.真是大手笔! － Titan 　2009-07-15 16:22 (0 bytes , 265reads )
牛王是个好同志. 要顶。 － 奔向小康 　2009-07-13 11:02 (61 bytes , 300reads )
这样的帖吾等 一定要顶 － xscheme 　2009-07-12 17:03 (0 bytes , 262reads )
这样的例子很多，就不再贴了。 － 牛魔王 　2009-07-12 15:38 (0 bytes , 280reads )
mermaid － 牛魔王 　2009-07-12 15:36 (58 bytes , 508reads )
牛市当中使用日线周期上的RSI 最有可能造成 － 牛牛5000 　2009-07-13 09:08 (241 bytes , 423reads )
midas － 牛魔王 　2009-07-12 15:23 (177 bytes , 565reads )
yangzijiang － 牛魔王 　2009-07-12 15:16 (184 bytes , 599reads )
YZJ在现在的价位很悬... － zhaijj 　2009-07-12 19:27 (25 bytes , 453reads )
yangzijiang 最近的走势是反向背离？ － sgCSM 　2009-07-12 19:21 (45 bytes , 407reads )
Positive divergence depends on the lows instead of － Gucci 　2009-07-12 21:23 (361 bytes , 394reads )
Chartnexus的RSI定义似乎和别的软件不同 － conjurer 　2009-07-13 10:51 (48 bytes , 450reads )
其实这种不是特别确定的案例有一种办法就是看相同板块的其他股票 － tangba 　2009-07-13 09:12 (63 bytes , 390reads )